『The Freer the Love, the Deeper the Wounds』
๐ฅ Movie Overview
๐ฌ Title: Sappho (2008)
๐ Country: ๐บ๐ธ USA / ๐ท๐บ Russia
๐️ Genre: Melodrama / Erotic / Period Drama
⏳ Runtime: 88 minutes
๐ข Director: Robert Crombie
๐️ Screenplay: Robert Crombie, Hristina Bojcheva
๐บ Platform: Amazon Prime Video (availability varies by country)
๐ฉ๐ผ Cast: Avalon Barrie – Sappho Lovell
Lyudmila Chiriaeva – Helen Orlov
๐งฉ Deep Story Exploration (Spoilers)
๐ Summer Lover
'Sappho' borrows the legend of the great ancient Greek poet Sappho and the island of Lesbos, where same-sex love is historically rooted. However, upon release, the film sparked heavy criticism and controversy among both critics and audiences due to its storyline and ending.
๐ฅ Love Triangle, Prelude to Rupture
Sappho arrives on Lesbos with her husband Phil, a painter, for their honeymoon. There, she meets the alluring Helen, daughter of a Russian archaeologist. Drawn irresistibly to Helen, Sappho begins to believe she is the reincarnation of the ancient poet. The three of them fall into a passionate sexual love triangle (mรฉnage ร trois).
Through her relationship with Helen, Sappho explores her sexual identity and pushes the boundaries of gender roles in her marriage. Yet, jealousy and conflict quickly transform this relationship into a storm. The film alludes to the legend of the ancient poet Sappho, who leapt from the cliffs of Lefkada in despair over unrequited love, and the modern Sappho also meets a tragic end.
⚡ Critical Analysis: Dishonoring the Name of 'Sappho'
๐ฉฑ Thematic Superficiality and Eroticism
The film’s major flaw lies in using the symbolic weight of the ancient poet Sappho and the island of Lesbos merely as an erotic backdrop rather than exploring their cultural and queer significance in depth.
- Origin of 'Lesbian': The word “lesbian” comes from the island of Lesbos, where Sappho wrote about love and friendship among women. Instead of honoring this heritage, the film reduces it to a sexually charged drama aimed at male audiences.
- Sappho’s Identity: While the protagonist claims to be the reincarnation of the poet and explores same-sex desire, it is portrayed less as a mature journey of self-discovery and more as impulsive, immature behavior.
๐ญ Core Criticism: The Heteronormative Ending
The ending is the aspect most fiercely criticized by queer film critics.
Sappho’s relationship with Helen ends in tragedy, leading to Sappho’s suicide. To make matters worse, Helen leaves with Phil after Sappho’s death, implying a return to a heterosexual endgame.
- Dead Queer Woman Trope: In queer narratives, the trope of the lesbian dying tragically reinforces the notion that homosexuality is doomed to fail or be punished. This film exploits that clichรฉ, reviving the tragic death of a queer woman while restoring heterosexual relationships as the norm, provoking major backlash.
- Helen’s Characterization: Helen awakens Sappho’s same-sex desire but is ultimately portrayed as saying, in effect, “it’s only for when men are not around, real love is with a man.” This undermines her character’s integrity and consistency.
๐ธ Lack of Aesthetic Completion
The film attempts to showcase the beauty of a Greek island and 1920s costumes but suffers from weak direction and screenplay flaws.
- Poor Direction: Shaky handheld camerawork, inconsistent character portrayal, and dialogue-heavy reliance (“tell, don’t show”) highlight the lack of visual storytelling.
- Character Inconsistency: Sappho is depicted as jealous and capricious, making it difficult for audiences to empathize with or connect to the protagonist.
๐ An 'Erotic Drama' That Left Only Controversy
Sappho recorded box office success in Ukraine, but at the same time provoked religious protests and petitions for a ban, igniting widespread controversy.
Although borrowing the name of the ancient poet, the film fails to respect or explore women’s love. Instead, it perpetuates outdated heteronormativity and queer tragedy clichรฉs. Beyond provocative eroticism and the exploitation of Sappho’s name, critics argue that the film lacks both thematic depth and artistic merit.
๐ฏ Personal Rating
๐ Love Scene Intensity: ♥♥♥♥♥
⭐ Rating: ★★
No comments:
Post a Comment